This Discussion Board is for men who
find it difficult or impossible to urinate in a public or social situation. Women should use the women's Board.
The Board is maintained and moderated by the
U.K. Paruresis Trust. Registered Charity no: 1109541.
For
further information, visit our website, or contact us at
I was impressed with the Draft 'Design Guidelines for Public Toilets' and wondered if anyone had seen this article in Nursing Times?
Toilet practice offends dignity 9 November 2010 | By Ben Clover "NHS organisations have complained about cleaning staff of the opposite gender entering single-sex toilets. Organisations responding anonymously to a Department of Health consultation on hospital cleaning standards complained that “privacy and dignity” was affected when male cleaners entered female toilets that were in use, or vice versa. One respondent said: “This poor practice is potentially resulting in offences to decency every time an opposite sex worker arrives to inspect or clean. This is totally unacceptable and is undermining what nurses are trying to achieve. “Nurses are striving to promote privacy and dignity and single sex facilities on the wards, this must be extended to other areas of the hospital if a culture of equality is to be achieved.” The “discomfort and distress” toilet users might feel when a cleaner of the opposite sex entered could even be regarded as harassment under sex discrimination legislation, one NHS body warned in its formal response. Respondents blamed management and cleaning contractors for the problem. “There appears to be confusion amongst cleaning companies and facility managers regarding the relevant employment legislation and how it applies to situations involving cross sex observation” one said. The consultation responses were among the 458 received by the DH, National Patient Safety Agency and the British Standards Institution after they invited organisations to comment on new hospital cleanliness standards. The responses were revealed to Nursing Times after a Freedom of Information request. The consultation closed in February. A DH spokeswoman said there was no date set for releasing the new standard".
The guidelines you suggest might go someway towards addressing privacy issues in all its many guises including those around gender which appear to compound the whole privacy/decency/anxiety scenarios for some people!
Re: PRIVACY
Posted by Jane on 3/1/2011, 4:51 pm, in reply to "PRIVACY"
It seems to be common practice now for toilets in shops to be cleaned by people of the opposite sex during opening hours. Not a good development in my view. And at the New Years Eve fancy dress party I went to, both times I went into the ladies, there were men there in drag!!! (No I didn't go.)
Re: PRIVACY
Posted by Hammerji on 4/1/2011, 8:09 am, in reply to "Re: PRIVACY"
Hi Jane Remember, there is no legal right for a man to be in a female toilet or vice versa so you have every right to ask them to leave, or ask a manager to, whether it is a cleaner or men in drag! It is only legal if you do not object, and out of respect any cleaner/worker of the opposite sex should have some means of checking there are no current users and wait till people have finished. They should not be in there with someone, or walk in on you as they, or you, could be accused of improper behaviour, or they could be on their own with a minor. There are good practice guidelines for cleaners and it is effectively sexual harassment when you get down to it if you are made too uncomfortable to use the facility! If more people complained to management (and may be their MP) this undignified and humiliating practice would soon stop!In some areas eg sports centres they are using opposite sex workers in changing rooms too-a wonderful job for perverts who can just knock and open the door and look in and get paid for it!